Koozali.org: home of the SME Server

Legacy Forums => General Discussion (Legacy) => Topic started by: dave_d on January 29, 2004, 06:37:31 PM

Title: An undocumented feature!
Post by: dave_d on January 29, 2004, 06:37:31 PM

Hello All!!

I wonder if anyone can comment on the following .....

Using SME 6.0, create two ibays.

ibay 1 .....

Name:  t1
Desc:  t1
Group: Admin
User Access:  Write = Admin, Read = Group
Public Access:  No access
Exec of dyn content: Disabled


ibay 2  .....

Name:  t2
Desc:  t2
Group: Everyone
User Access:  Write = Group, Read = Everyone
Public Access:  FULL access
Exec of dyn content: Enabled


Now look at the ibays using the File Explorer on a Windows 98 box.

t1 cannot be seen - that's OK because of the ownership
t2 can be seen

Now modify t1 so that

Owner Group = Everyone
User Access:  Write = Group, Read = Group.

Using the Windows explorer again ...

t1 can be seen, is empty, and can have things created in it (say fred.txt)

Looking now at t2

t2 can be seen, contains directories .AppleDesktop, files, html, and cgi-bin.  Cannot create anything in here (no error messages given by Windows)
Go to \files and everything works OK - a file can be created (say jim.txt)

Now, to me, this seems to be inconsistant behaviour.  In the first instance the Linux directory /home/e-smith/.../ibays/t1/files is presented to the Windows explorer as //Server/t1.  In the second instance the directory /home/e-smith/.../ibays/t2 is presented as //Server/t2 and the /home/e-smith/.../ibays/t2/files directory is seen as //Server/t2/files.  I would have expected the ibays to appear the same to Windows.

The difference seems to be that in the t1 case the directories (in the Linux world) end up as admin:shared whereas the t2 files end up as root:shared.

Now, as I was using the SME6 administration 'web site' to do all this, I must come to the conclusion that what I see is an undocumented feature (!) and so I just thought I would document it and see if anyone can tell me why this happens.

Regards,

Dave

Title: An undocumented feature!
Post by: Boris on January 29, 2004, 08:01:02 PM

If you don't enable websharing, you don't need to see html and cgi-bin folder and share assigned directly to "files" folder.
If you enable web access to t1 ibay, folders will look the same as t2. It has always been that way.

Title: An undocumented feature!
Post by: jok11n on January 30, 2004, 12:50:22 AM

You have the properties of the two ibays set differently. If you set them the same they will behave the same, either both for dynamic, or both without. If you set it to enable dynamic content you will see all the folder, this is normal

Title: An undocumented feature!
Post by: Anonymous on January 30, 2004, 09:03:57 AM

Thanks for your comments.  As long as the behaviour is what the designers meant, that's fine by me!  What you say makes sense - it just seems a bit inconsistent at first sight.

Dave