Anthony, do you have to have the allow password option set to NO for the public key procedure to work properly?
I'm asking because I am presently away from my server and have already locked myself out once and was able to talk someone through the procedure to change the allow password option back to yes so I could get back in. However, when I try to log in with the SSH2 RSA key method, while the password option is set to yes, it tells me the key is rejected and asks for the password. Does that sound right?
I need to do the exact same thing you are doing with PuTTY. However, I am using the PuTTYgen key generator. Should I be making SSH1 RSA keys?
I tried your method and it still didn't work, but I still had the password option set to yes.
Thanks!
Tom Carroll