tviles,
Don't turn off RAID. I assume you have RAID5, which is what you get with 5 disks (or 4 or 6....)but you also get a level of redundancy with RAID.
ie you can recover if one of the disks dies. Without RAID, if the disk dies, you lose its contents. So, unless you have some other backup strategy (AND USE IT FREQUENTLY), keep the RAID array.
I would suggest that,if they really are getting old, you replace the disks with newer ones.
Remember, it may only be a home server, but the data will be precious to someone.
Cheers
Ian