moe
By the way, if you newly rebuilt server is truly a server, it should have a fixed (static) IP. Makes for a much more stable network when many PCs have to find the server - they know where it lives and don't have to ask. The Bold/Italic/Underlined is to emphasise that static IP would be a better way to go.
The way to achieve this using DHCP, is to setup a Hostname entry in server manager Hostname & addresses panel, & specify the mac address of the Windows server NIC, & also specify the required fixed IP to be allocated to the Windows server.
The SME DHCP server will always then allocate the same (specified) IP to the Windows server, so oteh end result is a"fixed" IP.
Make sure the IP you specify is outside the automatically allocated DHCP IP range, also see another server manager panel where you can review this range. That range can be set in the Console under the "Configure this server" option menu.
There is also a setting change you can make for the MasterBrowser issue, so that the SME server has a higher value & will always be the MasterBrowser server on the network, search the Forums, & if you cannot find this ask here again & I will look up my notes. Google also should find plenty of info.